Sorry if I seemed to come off as critical, that was definitely not my intention. And welcome to domain investing and to NamePros!
I was just pointing out that, even if you view it as advice only for you (I did not read it that way, sorry for misunderstanding) that you might want to consider options not on your original list. As you say, people could vote none of the above.
@Pay.My.id does a nice job above outlining how the answer could be different depending on your considerations.
I think the answer depends on whether your goal is to quickly sell domain names to other investors at modest increases (say you buy a domain name for $20 and are happy to sell it for $75). If so, the registrar marketplaces work, as does NamePros. While Afternic is a great choice for many (see below) if you were selling at that level the minimum commissions would eat up a lot of your profits.
If you are planning to buy a domain name for $100 to sell for $3500, and if it is a brandable name, then, despite their commissions, the brandable marketplaces makes sense. But keep in mind that odds are you will need to wait a long time for a sale.
Afternic has the biggest network, so they do get traffic, independent of your landers being there.
DAN are growing rapidly, innovating in a number of ways, and I think their is general agreement that their landers are outstanding. They also offer payment plans. Also, they have no minimum commission, and their 9% rate is less than Afternic and way less than the brandable places. People will mainly find your names by your lander being there (although general traffic on DAN is definitely growing).
I hope you find one that is the right choice for you. By asking others to vote, they probably need to know a bit more though, if the poll is as you say intended only for you. For example:
- Your names are under 60 day lock - does that mean they are hand reg?
- Are they .com or something else?
- Typically what price do you plan to ask?
- Do you plan to use the landers at the marketplace?
- Do your domains appeal to particular geographical areas?
- Do you think payment plan option is important for sales of your names?
- Do you want to use BIN or Make Offer, and do you think having agents involved would help close sales of your names?
- Do you want to be able to include logos or other features in presentation?
Anyway, best wishes in finding marketplace(s) that work for you. And welcome once more!
Bob
PS Another way to get an answer to your question would be to browse the thread Report Completed Sales Here to see where people are selling names. While it is self-reported, and many do not report there, it does include venues that are not reported to NameBio.