Here is what i found:
80,900 exact match results for "Sexiest Athletes" on google.
EstiBot Value: $ 850 USD
exact match searches per month: 1k+
some related sales:
nakedathletes.com was sold on 2007-11-11 for 949 usd
topathletes.com was sold on 2015-05-15 for 1,140 USD
primeathletes.com was sold on 2013-02-18 for 1,888 USD
littleathletes.com was sold on 2011-06-29 for 2,500 USD