This thread is helpful because I feel like I've blown 2 sales this week because I failed to name a price at first request. I was so afraid of leaving money on the table! Luckily, both failed conversations happened on the first day I listed the names, so hopefully there's time for redemption.
Hi
all answers or replies are not definitive, in that they have to be applied to your strategy.
or what you did was the right or wrong thing to do
they are just responses to a situation, at a particular moment in time.
meaning....
can change, depending on the specific domain and time.
for instance, other day I got email asking if a NNL.com I have, is for sale.
(now mind you, it's on privacy by default and the inquirer sent the email to the privacy addy)
so, I replied, "what's your offer"?
they replied with 4 figure amount
and I replied, "Thanks, but it's too low to consider"
I didn't give a price either, and I still own the domain
if they want it, then they will submit a higher offer, if not, then i'll forget about it.
moral of the story, sometimes you leave money on the table, simply because it's not enough.
imo...